Day Two

Ok, so I’m slow to start this. A little busier than I thought I would be…rehearsals, writing a children’s education book, teaching, gigging, practicing, cooking, working out, working on tour in the Midwest in the Fall, planning out my summer…however, here’s the next installment.
Today, I had to drive up to Armonk, NY to teach some great kids and enroute I remembered I had this amazing box set of Ella Fitzgerald, 12 nights in Hollywood, in my glove compartment. I figured, hey, I’ve got at least an hour to get home (rain, Friday night, stupid drivers) - let’s do my listening now and make my drive seem faster.
The recordings were taken at the now extinct Los Angeles club, Cresendo, in 1961 and 1962. If you are an Ella fan, I would highly recommend this box set. I’ve actually listened to the whole thing, but figured I’d go back and see what I hear this time around. Ella Fitzgerald on vocals, Herb Ellis on guitar; Paul “Scooby” Smith or Lou Levy on piano; Gus Johnson or Stan Levey on drums.
My first impression (that I recall thinking previously), is that she takes chorus after chorus on every tune. Some tracks are under two minutes, others are over five, but on this particular CD, no one in her band actually takes a solo. This strikes me because most jazz singers today tend to usually to sing one, maybe two choruses up front, then there are solos by the band, perhaps some trading, and then a chorus out. I’m not saying I’m exempt from this, but generally, that’s the m.o. And not only for singers - instrumentalists as well. Perhaps it’s just the way it’s evolved, but Ella takes no prisoners. In particular, on the Duke Ellington tune Take the A-Train, she takes an almost seven minute scat - sometimes utilizing the lyrics, sometimes scatting, but always interesting. It’s a pretty simple AABA form tune, so to take an almost seven minute vocal solo is pretty, well, awesome.
I am also struck by how engaging and ridiculously fun her scatting is. I don’t like scatting. I don’t like listening to scatting. But I like Ella scatting. There is something utterly unique and unpretentious about her movement through the changes. She makes me want to practice scatting, if only for my own fun and learning (which, in my opinion, is where a lot of it should stay). I’m not against vocal improvisation, and it can be amazing to listen to when coming from an honest and pure place; but the actual act of scatting over changes that is time and again done by jazz singers that don’t really know what they’re doing, are only doing it because they think they should, or don’t have any emotional attachment to their scat just shouldn’t happen as much as it does. I understand the desire to do more than deliver a melody and lyric, but in the end, that’s our job. To tell stories. So, tell the story. Again. Use the lyrics to create an improvisation. Write a vocalese that advances the story. Interact with the band - singing guide tone lines, singing riffs, inserting sounds - just be honest. People will listen.
I digress. Back to Ella. You can barely hear Herb Ellis on guitar. There is a lot of piano. A lot of walking bass. Swinging from the tush drumming. Very stylistic for the time. To be honest, I don’t think Mr. Ellis really adds anything to the music except perhaps some ambient sound and I doubt most laymen listeners would even notice his presence. I am very grateful that I play with an amazing guitarist who does more than just chunk chords.
She sings some rather obscure standards that you don’t hear much these days. Their sentiment hasn’t withstood the test of time: My Heart Belongs to Daddy, Accentuate the Positive, Across the Alley from the Alamo, and On a Slow Boat to China. I love Accentuate the Positive - such a fun, silly song that I used to sing as a child and that I sing in the shower, but Ella does it with a full band, no pretenses, and takes multiple choruses. Amazing.
I think my favorite track on the first disc (which is all I got to on my way home) is Round Midnight. It opens with her talking to the lighting engineer and asking for some “sexy light…not that it would help any…” The audience laughs and the song begins. It’s a beautiful ballad wonderfully executed by Ella, and the cadenza she sings at the end a cappella is simply sublime. I have rewound that part of the track many times and can now sing along with Ella as she finishes this beautiful Monk tune. I do wish that there was less instrumentation on this. Perhaps just bass. Just piano. Alas, as with many recordings of that era, it just wasn’t done so much.
She ends with her trademark, Mr. Paganini, graciously thanking the audience with her up-bending “thank yous” Again taking multiple choruses, she is funny, witty, and engaging and I once again am in awe of this woman from whom so many jazz singers have learned and continue to love.

